Session Review Notes
Period 1973[Oct- Dec]
Artist:Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons
Bob Crewe Late 1973 Sessions Frankie Valli[ Four Seasons]
[lncluding Kenny Nolan, Charlie Calello and Nick Massi and a Four Seasons including Gerry Polci and Lee Shapiro, Joe Long and Demitri Callas]
Core Tapes to be researched: P2664:
Track Title: My Eyes Adore You-Title on Artists Card!! [Alternative Mix found and proposed for release Summer 2020]
Artist: Frankie Valli
Producer: Bob Crewe
Motown Master: 62522
First Location Tape: P2664
Second Location: T5178
Additional Location: P5085[Album]
Notes
It's very interesting studying the Artists Card for 'My Eyes Adore You' which shows the first stereo mix done on 11th December 1973 and copies done to T tape 5178 but then again some 6 months later on 4th and 10th June.(the second one being to P5085 the mysterious album tape Motown assembled that month). So then there is the note “mixes out to producer” in red and “tune sold back to producer”.
This raises the question of 'when' was it sold?. Perhaps it was as late as June 1974 and that is when Crewe/Valli/Gaudio started 'hawking it around' to other Record Companies before signing Frankie Valli up to Private Stock.? Does anyone know more?
Charles Calello told us he put added strings on the copy purchased for release in late 1974. This copy remains in Motown’s vault as the original Master and we found a Tape Box of a ‘New Mix?’ version in the FSP Archives. It has a louder guitar in the mix and a different vocal outro from Frankie which is not as effective as the version later released on Private Stock. We have proposed this version for inclusion as a Bonus Track in the Box Set ‘unreleased’ tracks Disc 22.
Track Title: Hymn To Her [found and for release Summer 2020]
Artist: Four Seasons
Producer: Bob Crewe
Motown Master: 62523
First Location Tape: P2664
Second Location: T5198[78?]/T5767
Additional Location: P5085[Album]
Notes
The administrators that did the Artists Cards at Motown in 1973 didn't always get the right 'gender' message as the data for Master Nr 62523 shows.[Titled ‘Hymn To You’ !!] This magnificent Bob Crewe-Kenny Nolan song just oozes quality and the anthemic 4 Seasons which we know include Nick Massi lift it to another level. Frankie Valli may have wanted to get away from his falsetto hence the focus on 'My Eyes Adored You' rather than this but it is suggested he did try to buy 'other masters' from the label in Rex Woodard's article from Billboard in 1981. He now knows the superb master for this still exists and that fans would love it as we have put the acetate on You Tube since 2011 when we uncovered it. Mixed as early as 11th December 1973 and subsequently copied to album Tape P5085 which we now know had tracks added in May 1974 all too late for a frustrated group and producer and never released. Bob Gaudio already had plans to take this group in a new direction and Frankie Valli wanted to re-establish himself separately as a solo performer. Did Frankie Valli's solo ambitions eventually destroy the Four Seasons sound?.....answers on a postcard to......The Four Seasons Partnership c/o...!!!........it is however ESSENTIAL FOUR SEASONS. The mix approved by Bob Gaudio for inclusion in the Snapper Box Set is different to the copy we found in the FSP Archive....it had been there since 1974??....and is the same choir fade-in start as the acetate. It has been proposed for inclusion in the Box Set as an alternative Mix.
Track Title: Lovers [found and for release Summer 2020]
Artist: Four Seasons
Producer: Bob Crewe
Motown Master: 62524
First Location Tape: P2664
Second Location: T5198
Additional Location: P5085[Album]
Notes
This is one of the last unreleased recordings from the November 1973 sessions with Bob Crewe and Kenny Nolan and the Four Seasons that included Lee Shapiro and Gerry Polci. Charlie Calello was the arranger and Nick Massi also arranged the vocals and contributed to the harmonies. We have salvaged an acetate copy and posted the recovered version of this on You Tube since 2011, but this card confirms all we had from the Tape Index was correct. Bob Gaudio has mixed and approved a version for inclusion on the Snapper Music Box Set. It is on P2664 but was mixed and copied to P5085 in May 1974 which was the album assembled for release as Crewe/Valli/Gaudio decided to leave the label and try to take the songs they had done. It's a pity this one couldn't be bought along with 'My Eyes Adored You' as it would probably have sold well.
The FSP Archive actually contained an alternative mix with slightly different closing which we believe was the final mix selected for copying to the cancelled album tape. It has been proposed for inclusion in the Box Set.
Track Title: You've Got To Make Your Tomorrow Tonight
Second Location: T5198
Notes
This track has been found as an acetate demo but begs the question....Why?. It is a Wonder Who styled song of ‘novelty’ quality but was completed. It can be heard on our You Tube channel ‘Mowest Chameleon’. Maybe it is more a joke by Bob Crewe to wind-up Motown Execs.? But whilst interesting it isn't a strong addition to the groups catalogue although done at the same sessions as the above tracks and with the same personnel.
Track Title :Hickory [Extended Version]
Artist: Four Seasons
Producer: Bob Crewe
Motown Master: 62521
First Location Tape: P2664
Notes
Although a released 45 - Motown 1288FA we found an acetate in 2011 of the ‘Extended’ version with an extra verse and a superb Frankie Valli falsetto ending. Whether it has been found or reviewed by Bob Gaudio is unclear as he identified that he did NOT WANT the extended version of ‘Charisma’ included in the Box Set even though it was included in the 2008 Motown Anthology 2 CD Box set.!!! Obviously it should be.....but why a NO from him when I sent him the Master of ‘Charisma’ Extended?
The version we have of ‘Hickory Extended’ is on You Tube here, but there is no evidence the version has survived but if so it should be on Tape P2664.....and should be released.
There are rumoured other tracks from this session tape to be confirmed via listening tests which given the volume of Tapes involved may not have happened yet and most certainly Universal Motown are not allowing anything else to be included in the Box Set and Bob Gaudio is not approving anything else for this project
Next Time......Summary/Conclusions
Ken Charmer – Music Historian
Recent Comments